Saturday, October 13, 2012

Case study on Victimhood, trip to former USSR




If I did not know so many Ukrainians personally, learnt about your values, struggles and extraordinary difficulties, I would probably have the same attitude as most of the world seems to show for you as a Nation: indifference or flat-out disdain.   Admit it: which group of nations (I. e. EC, the Western World at large, etc.) wants to assimilate, incorporate or even closely relate to a country known by such deep corruption at all levels, unsafe because of tainted police and judiciary, and a population that learned work-ethics under the Russians under one form of oppression or another. Add to it the way Ukraine purportedly dealt with the ‘Jewish problem’, to complete a very unattractive (to put it mildly) definition of what Ukraine is, today, to the rest of the world.

But I know, befriend and work with many young Ukrainians, I learned (some) of this Country’s history and plight so I am not ready to discard Ukraine into the corner of the unredeemable, disposable and discarded group of nations that are hopeless.

If I understand it correctly, briefly put, this is a Nation that is not quite yet.  It is Ukraine, has a beautiful flag and some of the most aesthetically pleasant and elegant youth, found anywhere in the world.  At the same time, half your Country considers themselves something else before/besides Ukrainian, namely Russian.  In a sinister schizophrenic message, your are taught your own language at schools, you fly your own flag, but the underlying message is that your own literature, art, history and achievements are dim, as comparing with the larger, richer, assertive and brutal neighbor that dominated every aspect of your life during the past 500 years or so.

In the mind of many Ukrainians, a close relationship with Russia is a necessary evil. Ukraine is a serf to Russia, it always has been and will forever be, according to that misguided belief.  This is probably the most blatant example of Stockholm Syndrome, ever.  Until that ‘issue’ is resolved, I can’t imagine any semblance of true Freedom to take place in your magnificent land.

Ukraine is married to Russia. Not on even ground, not a Western Style marriage, but one of an overpowering and brutal husband and a complacent, abused wife (or mistress) that deep inside, believes she deserves to be abused and punished, and asks for more.  Ukraine needs to find a marriage counselor to guide it to a divorce, friendly or otherwise.   The problem with abusive husbands is that the abuse increases with time, is not stable.  As the police reports from any city will attest, in many cases the abused wife gets murdered.  Looking back in your common history, how many Ukrainians died from such abuse?  Holodomor (Stalin’s written orders to shot anyone in Ukraine found hiding food is public record), Chernovil, the invasion of Afghanistan with so many Ukrainian troops, the gulags…)   One could see that they were all victims of a ruthless, abusive, controlling ‘husband’.

To the credit of many in Ukraine, you recently attempted to divorce Russia and join the rest of the civilized world as an independent nation.  Utilizing Europe’s need for gas, Russia managed to frustrate your attempt of ascension to the EC.  Coward European governments turned their back on  you, and ‘delivered’ you back to Russia.  Obama did not help you either, as in their ‘Reset’ strategy with Russia, Obama sold you out to your former kingpin. Yes, you got screwed big time.   From the distance, reading about Ukraine based on statistics as for productivity, work-ethics, high incidence of HIV, you are a ‘playable pawn’, not worth of sharing tears about.  What does the rest of the world has to lose, while it could cool things down with the KGB Coronel now in charge of Russia?

But you are not just a pawn to be played, sacrificed and discarded.  From my personal experience (one that most people in the West DO NOT have), Ukraine is a hidden treasure with amazing people, suffering from centuries of oppression.   What the rest of the world does not know, is that Ukrainians at large have tremendous potential and riches. If what does not kill you makes you stronger, if Australia, USA, Japan, Brazil, and so many other nations are the result of tremendous pain and injustice, of bloody battles to fight injustice and claim independence, of embattled immigrants working against all odds (and powerful armies), to become some of the brightest success stories of all time; Ukraine has accumulated so much of that ‘adversity potential’, that once unleashed, could surprise the whole world, and themselves with unparallel success.

Nations do not prosper under ‘prosperity’, but as a reaction to, and with the tools learned though, adversity.  All that adversity, all that suffering, deposits ‘credits’ in the ‘adversity box’.  Eventually, you draw from that box to build your prosperity.  We don’t learn from success, we learn from failure. We don’t get energized by happiness as much as we get on fire,  motivated, decided by anger born out of frustration, pain, injustice.   Ukraine has its coffers full of it… Soon will be the time you can start drawing from it to build your own success.  

That is if you have not been beaten up to submission, lost hope, develop your ‘national character’ around embracing serfdom, complacency and the inner conviction that all resistance is futile.  Some of you did.  The Russians tried very hard to teach you ‘a lesson’ on submission (Stalin said it took 2 famines to teach you a lesson).  Did they succeed?   The recent unveiling of a statue in tribute to Stalin, would indicate that you gave up.  The ridiculous defense of a monument to another mass murdered that hurt you so much, Lenin, is still standing by Khreshiatik.  Those are not just reminders of people that hurt you, the message is: come on, do it again, not only we deserve it, but we like it!

After divorcing Russia, you will need some serious therapy.   The larger issue is Victimhood.  You are in a catch-22 situation: if you believe you are not a victim, you are under the mistaken idea that you deserved all the pain, suffering and genocide you endured.  If you believe you are victims, you are still attached to your victimizer, you perpetuate the idea that you are not responsible for your situation (caused by others) and that  you will probably (and maybe justifiably) remain a victim.  Hard situation to be on, but you need to break out from it, if you have any aspiration at freedom.

As long as you are a victim, you will not be assertive and you will not be able to deal with the rest of the world in an harmonious, friendly and even basis.  Truth is that nobody wants to deal with victims, as sooner or later, your partners will be recognized as victimizers (per your invitation).  That is not a good relationship to have.

One piece of good news is that the world, at large, have no idea who you are.  Contrary to the overwhelming opinion and sentiment of most Ukrainians, the world does not think little about you, does not consider you to be any inferior, your women are not thought of as prostitutes, your men are not known as drunks.  The truth is that the world has no idea of who or what you are.  There are a lot of very serious and important events going on in the world, several wars, potential for Iran to develop nuclear weapons, Muslim extremist planting bombs, world economic crisis, the raise of China that many see as a threat, etc. etc. etc. Nobody is paying attention to Ukraine.   The perception of Ukraine is virgin in the minds of most of the world.  In the aspect of international recognition or even cognition, you don’t start from minus zero, but from zero.  This is much better to what so many of you fear, as you appear to be overly concerned of what other people think about you.  They don’t think bad, or good.  They don’t think about you.  This should be good news.


No comments: